The Risks of Rehoming a Dog Privately in South Africa
When you need to find a new home for your dog, posting an ad on Gumtree or a community Facebook group can feel like the quickest option. We understand why people do it — but we also know what can go wrong. This page is not here to judge you. It's here to help you make a safer choice.
What happens when you post your dog online
When you list a dog as "free to a good home" or for a small rehoming fee on a public platform, you lose control of who responds. You might get dozens of messages within hours — some from genuine families, some from people you wouldn't want anywhere near your dog.
The problem is that the people you want to reach — responsible, caring adopters — are usually the ones who go through rescues. Public platforms can also attract people whose intentions are not always clear or safe.
Who watches these platforms
Dog fighting rings
Free or cheap dogs are used as bait in illegal dog fighting operations. These groups actively monitor platforms like Gumtree and Facebook for "free to good home" listings. They often send women or couples to collect the dog — people who look friendly and normal — so the owner feels comfortable handing the dog over. In some cases, the dog may never be seen again.
Backyard breeders and puppy mills
Unsterilised dogs — especially purebreds and popular small breeds like Yorkies, Frenchies, and Maltese — are highly valuable to illegal breeders. They will take your dog, breed from them repeatedly in poor conditions, and discard them when they stop producing. They're skilled at telling convincing stories about the loving home they'll provide.
Flip-for-profit resellers
Some people make a living collecting free or cheap dogs and immediately reselling them at a higher price. They don't care about the dog's welfare — they care about the margin. The dog may be passed through multiple hands in a single week.
Warning signs to watch for
If you do choose to rehome privately, these are the behaviours that should make you pause:
- They're in a hurry. "I can collect today." "I'll take the dog right now, no questions asked." Genuine adopters want to meet the dog and understand their needs before committing.
- They don't ask about the dog. No questions about health, temperament, whether the dog is good with children, or why you're rehoming. Someone who doesn't ask doesn't care.
- They send someone else to collect. "My cousin will pick the dog up." You have no idea who is actually taking your dog or where they're going.
- They refuse a home check or won't share their address. If someone won't let you see where your dog will live, there's usually a reason.
- They offer more money than you asked for. This is a red flag — they're competing to secure the dog, and it's rarely for good reasons.
A safer way to rehome
You don't have to navigate this alone. Breed-specific rescue organisations across South Africa have been doing this work for years. They have experience spotting warning signs and guiding safer placements.
When you work through a rescue, your dog's new home is chosen carefully — not by whoever answered your ad first. The process is private, respectful, and designed to protect your dog. Rescues have experience spotting warning signs and guiding safer placements.
And yes — it's free. There is no cost for rehoming guidance through our partner rescues.
Ready to rehome safely?
Find the right rescue for your dog's breed and situation. Private, judgement-free guidance — at no cost to you.
Find a rescue →